Readify

Rodrigo gropes Deborah at the grocery store

Unorthodox: The Scandalous Rejection of My Hasidic Roots

Rodrigo gropes Deborah at the grocery store in an encounter that ruptures her expectation of safety in her own neighborhood. The scene moves from a brief, uncertain touch to a direct accusation and then to silence: Deborah tries to make the shopkeeper answer for what happened, but leaves without redress, carrying the cold, melting Italian ice she can no longer bear to eat.

The encounter

Deborah is standing over the sliding door of a box freezer, choosing between cherry and lemon Italian ice, when Rodrigo, who works for Mr. Mayer, brushes past her on his way to the back of the narrow store. She jerks away without thinking. Before she can close the freezer, she feels a hand on her butt and a distinct pinch. The sensation lasts only a split second, leaving her unsure at first; when she turns, however, she sees Rodrigo disappearing into the darkness of the back room.

Her first response is physical and immediate. Frozen for a moment, she holds the Italian ice in one hand and turns her back to the freezer as though to protect herself. Her face grows hot, and indignation burns in her throat. The narration emphasizes not only the touch but the shock of its location: this has happened on her own street, where she expects to be safe. Her anger rises as she walks toward the counter, her heels tapping on the hollow wooden floor.

Reporting the assault

At the counter, Mr. Mayer is bent over his account books, his hands shaking from Parkinson’s and the tips of his beard brushing the frayed ledger pages. Deborah places two quarters on the butcher-block counter rather than handing them directly to him, following the rule she knows. In the same ordinary transaction, she faces a harder decision: whether to tell him what his employee has done or leave without saying anything. Embarrassment makes her pause, but she calls his name, then raises her voice when he does not look up.

Deborah tells Mr. Mayer to warn his employee not to touch customers. The complaint is concise and explicit; she does not hide what happened behind a hint. Mr. Mayer stares at her with a blank expression. She first wonders whether he has failed to hear her, but then sees his lips move as if he intends to speak, while no words come out. His hands, described as withered claws, freeze above the counter. Instead of answering, he gathers her two quarters in one palm and pushes a wooden scraper wrapped in white tissue paper toward her. Deborah takes it reluctantly and leaves as the bell rings frantically above the door.

The accusation’s aftermath

Back at the house, Deborah crouches on the front stoop and watches pigeons fight over crumbs left in the yard. The Italian ice remains unopened between her palms. Its paper container softens as it melts, and cherry-colored liquid leaks through the bottom, running over her fingers in red streaks. The treat she had just chosen becomes something she cannot eat: she feels nauseated, and even imagining its cloying taste brings bile to her throat. She drops the sodden container into a metal trash bin; when she rises, the slate beneath her feet is stained by the spill.

The melting ice gives the encounter a visible residue, but it does not resolve the problem Deborah is trying to name. She thinks she should tell someone and imagines that her grandfather might go to the store himself, confront Mr. Mayer, and insist that the workers cannot do whatever they want. Her desire is for justice and for the assurance that she should be safe within her own Jewish community. Yet this imagined appeal remains separate from what she can actually bring herself to say.

Silence and vulnerability

Deborah cannot easily tell her grandfather what happened because she does not know how to describe it without facing the embarrassment again. She also fears that he might think the incident was somehow her fault, or that she was implicated in the story. The possibility of disappointing him compounds the original violation: even while she wants an older relative to intervene, she worries that asking for help may expose her to judgment. The account does not show her making that disclosure; it ends with her fear and uncertainty still unresolved.

The episode contrasts the community’s rules for protecting propriety with Deborah’s experience of actual vulnerability. Earlier, she knows rules governing when a girl may be alone with a man, yet the family leaves her alone with Moshe because he is her cousin and she treats those rules as merely for show. At the grocery, where she expects ordinary neighborhood safety, an employee touches her without consent. Her immediate accusation challenges the shopkeeper to recognize that breach, but his silence and substitution of a scraper for an answer leave her without communal confirmation or remedy. The scene’s significance rests in that gap: Deborah names what happened, while the adult with the power to respond does not speak.